“ I really enjoyed my dining experience. The ambiance is beautiful. The hibiscus spritz was so good! It was refreshing with a nice kick to it! For appetizer, I had the octopus. It was perfectly prepared, and it paired so well with the sauce and potatoes. My scallops entree was amazing, my guest had the salmon, she enjoyed it! The portion size was very good! The service was amazing. Lina was so attentive and personable. The flow of the dining was fast. I arrived at 445, and I had ample time to make it to my 7pm Broadway show without rushing. I would go back. ”

“ Immaculate experience and wished I had more time. Met a dear friend for a special dinner during my work break. Advised staff we were in a time crunch and they truly heard my words. Robin our waiter was pneumonial, kind, attentive and exceeded our expectations. The food was just as great as the service. Will absolutely go back for dinner again and again. Thanks Robin, I hope to see you soon again! ⭐⭐⭐ ”

“ We had an amazing experience at this restaurant! As soon as you walk in, it is STUNNING. The food was absolutely delicious — every dish was full of flavor, and the desserts were the perfect finishing touch. Our favorites were the meatballs, Cacio e Pepe & the Rib Eye. For drinks, the Old Fashioned and French 75. Our waitress, Nicole, went above and beyond to make sure we had everything we needed. She was friendly, attentive, and made us feel so welcome throughout our meal. The service and atmosphere together made it such a great dining experience. I highly recommend this spot — we’ll definitely be coming back! ”

“ Absolutely outstanding experience at Osteria Siciliano! From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with genuine warmth and hospitality. The atmosphere is cozy yet elegant — perfect for a family dinner or a romantic evening out. Every dish was bursting with authentic Sicilian flavor — the pasta was fresh, the seafood perfectly cooked, and the desserts were heavenly (the cannoli is a must-try!). The staff made us feel like family, attentive without being overbearing, and clearly passionate about what they do. You can tell every plate is made with love and tradition. We left full, happy, and already planning our next visit. Highly recommend Osteria Siciliano to anyone who loves true Italian food and heartfelt ”

“ We had a great authentic Italian dinner and highly recommend it. Our server, Allen, made the service 5 star. The highlight dishes were the porterhouse steak and cacio e pepe pasta, both were amazing. The other classic pasta was also very good. Both antipastis (roasted octopus and eggplant) were just okay, but the sides, sautéed mushrooms and roasted potatoes were fantastic. Overall, it was very good, and only the antipasti could be improved, everything else was perfect. ”